Because of its importance, I am posting here, in full, comment submitted today by Leendert Vriens of stopumts.nl . The message from Leendert Vriens was sent to Martin Pall already on June 14, 2021.
Someone did send me a preprint of: “Millimeter (MM) wave and microwave frequency radiation produce deeply penetrating effects: the biology and the physics”.
Your abstract starts with:
“Millimeter wave (MM-wave) electromagnetic fields (EMFs) are predicted to not produce penetrating effects in the body. The electric but not magnetic part of MM-EMFs are almost completely absorbed within the outer 1 mm of the body”
- So you [Martin Pall] separate electric and magnetic parts. The mm-wave electromagnetic fields used for wireless communications are composed however of photons and photons are well known to be elementary particles. Elementary means that they cannot be subdivided, not themselves nor in their interaction with other particles or any material. So in sentence 2 you make a very basic error. That should not be acceptable for any scientific publication. Also, everything based on this separation must be considered to be incorrect. I scanned a few more pages and saw some things that a good physicist would not appreciate. I am sorry, but if I were you I would withdraw this manuscript. I hope it is still time. [emphasis added DL]
With best regards,
Pall didn’t send an answer.
P.S. from DL
I think the advice of withdrawing manuscript because of shoddy science could, and should, be extended to all of Martin L. Pall’s rumblings on wireless radiation and health. No matter what anti-5G activists think.